make a list
10
15
20
w/e

per request of steeler

hopefully this thread can start some debates

put mines up in a sec

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Ben Roethlisburger
4. Drew Brees
5. Carson Palmer
6. Eli Manning
7. Derrick Anderson
8. David Garrard
9. Tony Romo
10. Matt Hassleback
11. Jay Cutler
12. Marc Bulger
13. Donovan McNabb
14. Phillip Rivers
15. Jeff Garcia
16. Jason Campbell
17. Vince Young
18. Matt Schaub
19. Jake Delhomme
20. Kurt Warner

Favre... oh wait

hmm

Manning
Brady
Brees
Palmer
D Anderson

... uh

Brady>Manning

Brady had the greatest offense ever around him and couldn't get it done when Spagnuolo outmatched Josh McDaniels.

Brady has good touch, poise and is easily a top 2 QB but Peyton is just more talented, reads defenses better, calls his own plays, etc. Brady finally had the pro bowl WRs that were always the reason that people called Peytons ability hinged. He didnt win with them.

He won w/ 3 groups of below average receivers. Without him they wouldn't of been the best offense ever. i know he has a great offense around him but Manning does too.

O-Line- Slight edge Pats
Running- Edge Colts
Receivers- close but slight edge pats

People's reasoning for saying he was better than Peyton prior to this year was because he won with subpar WRs. They gave him superior WRs and he wasn't able to win. Therefore the WRs had nothing to do with it and it was solely based on the offensive schemes and play calling. Peyton did all of that in the majority by himself.

Tom Brady is easily one of the greatest of all time because of his clutch and rings, but Peyton is more talented and put in the same situation as Brady with only switching QBs, Peyton would've been more successful.

i see what ur talking about but Brady still won 18 games ( most in one season ever) and threw for the most touchdowns in a single season. It's not like Peyton doesn't have any talent in his receiving core.

All that matters is the 10 table ring that will be sitting on Michael Strahan's hand on may 29th, not Tom Brady's.

for almost all of mannings career he has had wayne and harrison..two pro bowl receivers and usually a stud running back.

brady won 3 super bowls with basically jack shit as receivers. the best he has ever had before this season was deion branch..and we can see how well he is doing with matt hasselbeck

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Eli Manning
4. Ben Roethlisberger
5. David Garrard
6. Carson Palmer
7. Derek Anderson
8. Drew Brees
9. Tony Romo
10. Matt Hasselback

bradys superbowl's without vinatieri- 0

rex grossman
kyle orton
brian greese (now with the bucs)
vince young
michael vick