| | most overrated player and underated player |    |
|
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
xB-MiLL_2
Global Mod
Number of posts: 2148
Online Madden Names: WINDYxCITYxFLYA
Registration date: 2007-09-03
 |  Subject: most overrated player and underated player  Sat Mar 15, 2008 4:23 pm | |
| The most overated player, in my opinion, is andruw jones, his OBP is horrible, his career BA is horrible....all he does is hit for power, thats it
his range isnt wat it used to be since he got big, he is just overated
The most underated player is Ryan Zimmerman. Hes a great defensive player, hits for power, BA, and has a good SLG and OBP %.
what you think? |
|
 | |
PtP
Number of posts: 1406
Age: 21
Location: cleveland
Online Madden Names: pTpBRaYLoN17
Registration date: 2007-09-04
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sat Mar 15, 2008 5:13 pm | |
| underrated-B.J. Upton he is never talked about but any team that might win can use him he is fast versatile on defense and hits for a high average
-Bobby Abreu is overrated imo because he had high RBI numbersbut he played in the best offense most of the time he hit there where runners in scoring position and he really didnt do anything else last year but high RBI's |
|
| | |
TiTaNx10xViNcE
Admin
Number of posts: 2177
Age: 21
Location: E-Wood MD
Online Madden Names: PS3- Titan10Young, 360 - TiTaNx10xViNcE
Registration date: 2007-09-03
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sat Mar 15, 2008 5:41 pm | |
| Underrated- Nick Markakis
Overrated- Carlos Beltran |
|
| | |
jagsfan
Admin
Number of posts: 1647
Age: 26
Location: California
Registration date: 2007-09-03
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sat Mar 15, 2008 5:44 pm | |
| Underrated: Brandon Phillips
Overrated: Barry Zito |
|
| | |
TwEnTy20ViZioN
Number of posts: 40
Age: 22
Online Madden Names: TwEnTy20ViZioN
Registration date: 2008-03-10
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sat Mar 15, 2008 6:06 pm | |
| | PRiMeTiMe PeRforMeR wrote: | underrated-B.J. Upton he is never talked about but any team that might win can use him he is fast versatile on defense and hits for a high average
-Bobby Abreu is overrated imo because he had high RBI numbersbut he played in the best offense most of the time he hit there where runners in scoring position and he really didnt do anything else last year but high RBI's |
Right team, wrong player
Carl Crawford is the most underrated player.
Dontrelle Willis is the most overrated. |
|
| | |
PtP
Number of posts: 1406
Age: 21
Location: cleveland
Online Madden Names: pTpBRaYLoN17
Registration date: 2007-09-04
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sat Mar 15, 2008 7:39 pm | |
| | thecrunkologyst wrote: | | PRiMeTiMe PeRforMeR wrote: | underrated-B.J. Upton he is never talked about but any team that might win can use him he is fast versatile on defense and hits for a high average
-Bobby Abreu is overrated imo because he had high RBI numbersbut he played in the best offense most of the time he hit there where runners in scoring position and he really didnt do anything else last year but high RBI's |
Right team, wrong player
Carl Crawford is the most underrated player.
Dontrelle Willis is the most overrated. |
carl crawford is known to be one of the best players in MLB to people who are a average fan he was talked about constantly last all star break most people know he is great |
|
| | |
jagsfan
Admin
Number of posts: 1647
Age: 26
Location: California
Registration date: 2007-09-03
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sat Mar 15, 2008 7:47 pm | |
| | ^UCLA/Tenn/G-Town/UNC^ wrote: | Underrated: Brandon Phillips
Overrated: Barry Zito |
thats not wut i wrote  ..altho i agree with it lol |
|
| | |
PtP
Number of posts: 1406
Age: 21
Location: cleveland
Online Madden Names: pTpBRaYLoN17
Registration date: 2007-09-04
| |
| | |
jagsfan
Admin
Number of posts: 1647
Age: 26
Location: California
Registration date: 2007-09-03
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sat Mar 15, 2008 7:51 pm | |
| titans edited im sure ..i wrote Ryan Howard as most overrated just to ruffle his feathers  |
|
| | |
XxPhillyxFanxX
Number of posts: 2685
Age: 102
Registration date: 2007-09-04
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sat Mar 15, 2008 8:55 pm | |
| Overrated : Abreu/beltran/bonds/Richie Sexson/JD Drew/Prior
Underrated : Polanco(wish phils woulda put him @ third)/ |
|
| | |
xB-MiLL_2
Global Mod
Number of posts: 2148
Online Madden Names: WINDYxCITYxFLYA
Registration date: 2007-09-03
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sun Mar 16, 2008 12:29 am | |
| | XxPhillyxFanxX wrote: | Overrated : Abreu/beltran/bonds/Richie Sexson/JD Drew/Prior
Underrated : Polanco(wish phils woulda put him @ third)/ |
ya polanco is a beast...great D, great bat....never gets mentioned |
|
| | |
patriots3996
Number of posts: 2004
Age: 18
Location: mass.
Online Madden Names: patriots3996
Registration date: 2007-10-09
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sun Mar 16, 2008 5:07 am | |
| under: i dont even remmeber his name. he threw a 1 hitter vs the red sox last year. his curve was crazy with a fastball thats i guess u could hay fast. he on the mariners. i think its felix hernendez. i know its felix ____
over: Abreu |
|
| | |
jagsfan
Admin
Number of posts: 1647
Age: 26
Location: California
Registration date: 2007-09-03
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sun Mar 16, 2008 9:18 am | |
| | XxPhillyxFanxX wrote: | Overrated : Abreu/beltran/bonds/Richie Sexson/JD Drew/Prior
Underrated : Polanco(wish phils woulda put him @ third)/ |
How is Bonds overrated ... steroids or not hes one of the best hitters of all time ...his stats may have been down last year but its not like ppl consider him the best hitters in the league .. and he sucks in the field now but not like ppl are tryin to make it like hes good ..hes a 7 time NL MVP ..8 time gold glove winner... 14 time All-Star ...but again ..everybody knows he lost a step and noone tries to make him out to be the best hitter in the league still ...but hes still got a bat on him and would be a great DH for any AL team |
|
| | |
XxPhillyxFanxX
Number of posts: 2685
Age: 102
Registration date: 2007-09-04
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sun Mar 16, 2008 9:26 am | |
| Bonds is overrated b/c..... he used Roids...
Ppl still think he is sooo fucking good but he's not...
only way he's good is when he's shooting those needles in his arm... or w/e...
he can't hit for shit.. |
|
| | |
jagsfan
Admin
Number of posts: 1647
Age: 26
Location: California
Registration date: 2007-09-03
| | Subject: Re: most overrated player and underated player Sun Mar 16, 2008 9:33 am | |
| | XxPhillyxFanxX wrote: | Bonds is overrated b/c..... he used Roids...
Ppl still think he is sooo fucking good but he's not...
only way he's good is when he's shooting those needles in his arm... or w/e...
he can't hit for shit.. |
<<forgot hes been convicted for steroids and forgot steroids/strength is all it takes to hit a ball
<<forgot he also hit 28 HRs last year with 66 RBIs on a team where nobody could get on base and in a lineup he got no protetion in in a season he only play 126 games where he also got walked 132 times ... he was hitting over .300 most of the year .. (struggled down the stretch ...whole team did ..they were not good at all)
*waits for legit reason for "overrated" except "steroids"
nobody says that hes the best hitter in MLB ...they all say he would be a good DH on a AL team |
|
| | |
| | most overrated player and underated player | |
|
