u really cant say who the best ever was. stats wise hmmmm Marino, Favre, Manning..... Playoffs..... Brady, Aikman, Montana. remember aikman was between 7-10 wins before his first playoff defeat as well.... but i cant remember just how many he had before his first loss. but by the end of super bowl 30 he was liek 11-1 so u have to put him in the category of one of the best post season qb's ever.....